My hottest hookup in college

(All participants over 18)

Unlike Zack (from my other stories) who was my roommate and friend, Jake and I were always acquaintances. We were never that close since we went to different colleges and only met through mutual friends from each others’ softball teams.

Jake was incredibly fit even for an athlete and although he wasn’t built large like a weightlifter, he was super toned and packed with lean muscle from head to toe. Apart from his flexibility and athleticism, his toned, taut and almost slender build also hid the fact that he ran faster and did more pull-ups than anyone else on his team. Pulling his top off after a game one day, I realised that what seemed like a slim build at first was actually the most lean and muscled body I had ever seen.

Jake was popular, jovial and always flirtatious with everyone but in a silly way, and I never thought anything about it beyond some playful flirting back. One drunken night at a bar, we were out with a group of teammates from both of our colleges. Nearing closing time, we bumped into each other in the corridor leading to the bathroom - I was heading back to our table and he was heading into the bathroom. It was a narrow corridor and as we met, Jake placed both of his hands on my shoulders and pressed himself into me. I laughed and pushed him off me, but he persisted, running his hands up and down my shirt and commenting on the work I’d done in the gym recently.

Glancing from side to side in a drunken haze to make sure that no one was coming, I helped myself to his chest and felt up the tightest, leanest pecs and abs I’ve ever felt. Jake’s body was incredibly firm and my mind was starting to wander. With his hands still on my upper body too, we fumbled with each other this way for a few seconds. The alcohol ruined my inhibitions and my thumbs found their way over his t-shirt to his nipples which to my surprise drew out a soft moan instead of the expected protest.

Feeling myself hardening in my pants, I stumbled back to the table and that was the end of our encounter for the night. Things didn’t stop there though, and we started texting the day after, until it was painfully clear that we both wanted to meet right away to continue things. That evening, I found myself in an hourly hotel room for the first time - one that was situated in between our colleges which were pretty far apart. My heart raced when I heard the knock on the door. I opened it to find the slender boyish athlete on the other side, wearing a singlet that accentuated his shoulders and biceps, and with a small gym bag slung over his shoulder. It was his first time at a place like this too, I could tell, as he looked around the room while closing and latching the door. “I’m still pretty hungover dude,” he said as he put his gym bag down.

To my surprise, Jake seemed almost insatiable and eager to dive right in. While still standing facing me he wasted no time and started feeling up my upper body just like he did at the bar. I laid my hands on his bare shoulders, feeling the definition in his biceps and running my fingers up into the fine sprays of hair on his pits. As our crotches pressed into each other, our foreheads pressed together for a moment, and his hands lowered to grip my ass cheeks. At the same time, my hands ran under his singlet as I felt up his abs, skin-to-skin. With that, Jake leaned in, already desperate with an open-mouth kiss. Our tongues met immediately without any of the usual initial pecks on the lips. He tasted amazing as our tongues locked, and I ran my tongue over his perfect set of teeth. We continued till he pulled away, out of breath.

Without further words, he started tearing my clothes off and with a single motion, got rid of his singlet and shorts, revealing a naked body packed with lean muscle. Yet, he was the one telling me how hot he found me as we watched each other stiffen up rapidly as we stood next to the bed. Jake closed his eyes and went in for another kiss. Pressing myself into the naked body of this incredibly fit and cute friend of mine was a high and I lost my mind as I realised that he was licking up all the spit in my mouth as we kissed. Seeing him all desperate flipped a switch in me I never knew I had and without breaking our kiss I quickly pulled him down onto the bed, on top of me.

On the way over to the hotel we had already discussed what was coming next, and with him on top I eagerly wrapped my legs around his slender waist and my arms around his neck, pulling him into me. Jake obliged by thrusting into me. I realised that I hadn’t even had time to touch his rod and finally reached around to guide the tip of his erection to my entrance, all while we continued kissing and pecking on the lips. As his tip grazed against my hole, Jake gasped and his eyes widened and something new awakened in his eyes.

Removing himself from me, Jake went to his bag to pull out a box of condoms and a bottle of lube. I held my legs open, exposing myself to him as I watched him dig through his bag desperately to retrieve the condoms and lube before lunging back on top of me to kiss me. I reached around behind him and unwrapped a condom (while still kissing) and by some feat wrapped it over his tool which was painfully hard by now.

Without saying anything, Jake maintained eye contact, sat up and lubed himself up. He looked like a starving animal as my hands ran up and down his bare upper body and he moaned as I ran my thumbs over his perfect dark nipples. Then, he climbed back on top of me, with his left hand supporting his weight next to my head, and his right hand guiding himself inside me.

I gasped as Jake slid in smoothly with total ease and the look of surprise on his face showed that he wasn’t expecting it either. But looking at my naked friend on top of me made me more receptive than I knew I could be. As he bottomed out, I felt myself being owned by him in the moment when pelvis pressed up into my cheeks, indicating that his full length was now inside me. To my surprise I felt Jake’s rod suddenly and firmly press up on my insides as he shifted his weight and with that a guttural moan escaped my lips. Jake’s eyes widened again, in awe at the sensation and my unexpected reaction.

Even at this point, no words had been exchanged between the two of us and we were driven purely by instinct. This continued as before Jake could ask if he could start thrusting I was already reaching around to pull his lower back and ass toward me, urging him on. I looked up at the naked athlete losing all of his inhibitions, huffing and grunting as his mouth hung open and he put his developed core muscles to work, rolling his hips in and out. Any doubt that he was new to this vanished as he expertly went to work with a steady but firm rhythm. Jake clearly was incredibly talented at working a guy over and in less than a minute had me moaning involuntarily. I grabbed his shoulders and looked up only to find him entirely lost in pleasure.

After just a minute or so, Jake’s breathing got heavier and his thrusts became more and more insistent. Having lost our inhibitions, I wanted nothing more than for this fit stud to finish in me as quickly as he could and I could tell that he felt the same. I looked up at him and for the first time since our encounter started, blurted out the word “please” over and over again, pulling his head down so that our noses touched. “Don’t pull out,” I said as I tightened the grip of my legs around his slender but strong waist. This seemed to surprise Jake again and his eyes narrowed and his jaw slackened as he released himself into me. I held my legs open, trying to receive as much of him as I could. It took only a little more than a minute for him to finish, that was how excited we both were.

Jake collapsed on top of me, panting, as I felt him soften inside of me. As a sheen of sweat started to form on his back, I rubbed my hands across his broad shoulder blades, as we both panted and soaked in the silence. We would go on for two more rounds that night and many more in the days to follow.