Down Sweater Sizing

Hey everyone. I’m looking for some guidance on Down Sweater sizing.

I’m deciding between an XS and a S. XS is a more snug fit without feeling tight, especially if I just have a tshirt on underneath. With a sweater on underneath it’s still comfortable and not restrictive, although there’s not really room for growth. It’s also just a bit shorter than I’d like. S has a better length and much more room for layering. With just a tshirt it feels floaty, and even with a sweater underneath it kind of feels like the jacket is hovering around me if that makes any sense. The chest/torso area feels loose.

There are elements I prefer from each one. When I’m wearing the XS I find myself wanting the length of the S, but when I’m wearing the S I wish it were more snug. I’m in Philly so I won’t be doing much layering - a sweater/sweatshirt on top of a tshirt is about as much as I’d ever need underneath.

XS is on the left and S is on the right in all the pics. Some measurements for reference: - 5’7” - 137 lbs - 28” waist - 38” chest

Thanks all, enjoy the rest of the holiday season!